The call: Go to Izumi Sushi & Hibachi, 312 E. Nine Mile Rd. if you want the closest match to Yamato’s hibachi-and-sushi format—especially if an all-you-can-eat option appeals.

Real-time local factors

• A recent Pensacola listing identifies Izumi as a newer all-you-can-eat sushi and hibachi spot at 312 E. Nine Mile Rd.
• Listed hours are 11 AM–9 PM Monday–Thursday, 11 AM–9:30 PM Friday–Saturday, and 11 AM–8 PM Sunday; confirm before leaving, since I could not independently verify today’s service.
• It is on the northeast side, so it is not a quick replacement if you were going to the former New Warrington Road Yamato site.

Runners-up

• Kobe Japanese Steakhouse — better if you want the more traditional tableside steakhouse/hibachi experience rather than all-you-can-eat.
• Kalbi Ichiban — better if you want Korean barbecue plus sushi/Japanese options rather than a straight Yamato-style dinner.

What flips this: If you want the nearest replacement to the old Yamato rather than the strongest hibachi match, choose based on your starting neighborhood—Izumi may be a longer drive from west Pensacola.

👉 Are you starting from the New Warrington/west Pensacola area, and do you want hibachi grill seating or mainly sushi?